Mapping as Process
  • About Me Brief CV
  • Comparative Map History Cartography in the European Enlightenment Cartography: The Ideal and Its History Cartography (reviews) Harley's Cartographic Theories Mapping an Empire
  • Classified (with download links) Regular Format
  • Archive
  • Contributions dramatis personae
  • Contact

Mapping as Process

  • About/
    • About Me
    • Brief CV
  • My Books/
    • Comparative Map History
    • Cartography in the European Enlightenment
    • Cartography: The Ideal and Its History
    • Cartography (reviews)
    • Harley's Cartographic Theories
    • Mapping an Empire
  • Bibliographies/
    • Classified (with download links)
    • Regular Format
  • Archive/
  • Resources/
    • Contributions
    • dramatis personae
  • Contact/

Mapping as Process

A blog on the study of mapping processes: production, circulation, and consumption

Cartography: The Ideal and Its History

Mapping as Process

  • About/
    • About Me
    • Brief CV
  • My Books/
    • Comparative Map History
    • Cartography in the European Enlightenment
    • Cartography: The Ideal and Its History
    • Cartography (reviews)
    • Harley's Cartographic Theories
    • Mapping an Empire
  • Bibliographies/
    • Classified (with download links)
    • Regular Format
  • Archive/
  • Resources/
    • Contributions
    • dramatis personae
  • Contact/

Cartography: The Ideal and Its History
Matthew H. Edney

University of Chicago Press, 2019.
ISBN 978-0-226-60554-8 cloth; 978-0-226-60568-5 paper; 978-0-226-60571-5 e-book.
Order via the link at right

!! Read the reviews !!

“There’s no such thing as cartography, and this is a book about it.”

So runs the epigraph to the introduction to this exposé of the ideal of “cartography.” Cartography is a simulacrum, an image of a thing that never existed and that does not conceal a truth so much as conceals that there is none. Cartography is a vision, one that scholars and the public have actively sought to make real, but which nonetheless does not actually match the reality of how people produce, circulate, and consume maps. The ideal’s preconceptions are so deeply entrenched in modern culture that they are essentially invisible; they must all be dragged into the light and dismissed if we are truly to engage with maps and mapping in an effective and productive manner.

Contents:

1. Introducing the Ideal of Cartography

2. Seeing, and Seeing Past, the Ideal

• explains the processual approach, of delineating precise spatial discourses within which mapping takes place, threads of discourse that share mapping practices, and broad modes of mapping formed from multiple threads. Whereas spatial discourses are how mapping occurs, modes are more of a heuristic.

3. Cartography’s Idealized Preconceptions

• runs through the many preconceptions of the ideal of cartography, highlighting key misconceptions, such as the existence of a “cartographic language” that is somehow unique and distinct from other semiotic systems, or the insistence that maps must be graphic “pictures,” or … . Ultimately, these preconceptions present cartography as a singular and universal endeavor.

4. The Ideal of Cartography Emerges

• the multiple factors since 1800 that prompted the development of the ideal, from the adoption of statewide territorial surveys, to set theory, to the rise of personal mobility. The ideal’s preconceptions are thus not some logical series of propositions, but stem from historical trends, so that they are often contradictory.

5. Map Scale and Cartography’s Idealized Geometry

• a detailed history of one of the multiple factors in Chapter 4, specifically the concept of “map scale.” Map scale enshrines the conviction that all maps are properly proportional to the earth they represent, even as map scholars accept that this is manifestly impossible. The chapter reveals the insidious misconceptions engendered by the concepts of “large scale” and “small scale” and proposes the concept of resolution instead.

6. Not Cartography, But Mapping

• Despite some recent commentary, cartography is not yet dead, although the ideal deserves to be killed off. That cannot happen until all map scholars and the public ditch the ideal and its continued emphasis on “the map” and instead address “mapping.”

 

  • About/
    • About Me
    • Brief CV
  • My Books/
    • Comparative Map History
    • Cartography in the European Enlightenment
    • Cartography: The Ideal and Its History
    • Cartography (reviews)
    • Harley's Cartographic Theories
    • Mapping an Empire
  • Bibliographies/
    • Classified (with download links)
    • Regular Format
  • Archive/
  • Resources/
    • Contributions
    • dramatis personae
  • Contact/

Mapping as Process

Mapping as Process is a space for me to explore a new approach to understanding mapping and its history. The exploration will eventually contribute to a book of the same name.

Search Mapping as Process:

The books …

Comparative Map History and “the History of Cartography”: Methodologies, Institutions, and Idealizations in Brill Research Perspectives on Map History. Available from Brill in July 2025, in print and ebook ($87).

together.jpg

Cartography in the European Enlightenment, Volume Four of The History of Cartography, edited by myself and Mary Pedley. Available from the University of Chicago Press, in print and ebook ($500).

Edney_9780226605715.jpg

Available from the University of Chicago Press in paperback ($30), e-book ($10–30), or cloth ($90).

cover scan.jpg

Some paperback ($38) copies are still available, as well as the ebook, from the University of Chicago Press.

For notifications of new content:
a) add Mapping as Process to your favorite RSS application (I use reeder);
b) follow me on Mastodon: @mhedney@historians.social; or
c) subscribe to h-maps for occasional updates.

All images are used in accordance with academic “fair use” copyright provisions.
All text (c) Matthew H. Edney and is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Powered by Squarespace.